Introduction
The selection of the water heater for your home is more than a matter of personal preference, it requires other considerations. It is difficult to come up with a common view because consumers are divided almost equally on this problem. Data from the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) reveals a close race: about 45% of respondents opt for electric water heating systems, 40% choose the gas type, and 15% are undetermined or do not mind either. This division shows that every type of water heater possesses the unique advantages and disadvantages, and they might appeal to different users.
This decision has a huge influence on your energy bills, the comfort levels of your home, and the environmental impact of your home. It is imperative to consider several important factors while making a decision. Factors such as energy efficiency, cost-effectiveness, ease of installation, maintenance requirements, and safety considerations are part of the discussion. Having a clear insight into the differences between gas and electric water heaters helps you to find the one that will meet your home requirements, energy preferences, and savings objectives.
What is a Gas Water Heater?
Gas water heater is a type of water heating appliance that burns natural gas or propane as the fuel. The heaters use gas burners that are positioned at the bottom of the tank to heat the water. When hot water is needed, the burner gets lit and heats the water inside the tank, which is then passed through your home plumbing network.
A gas water heater is offered in both tank and tankless designs. Tank-style gas water heaters are designed to store a particular amount of hot water, which can vary between 20 to 80 gallons, based on the size of the unit. Tankless gas water heaters, on the other hand, work by heating water on demand and do not store hot water in a tank.
What is an Electric Water Heater?
An electric water heater is simply a device that uses electricity to heat water. In the tank there are one or two heaters (depending on the size of the unit) that are in water. When the sensors detect that the water temperature is below the set point, the heating elements are activated, heating the water to the desired temperature.
As with gas water heaters, electric models come in both tank and tankless variations. Tank type electric water heaters store hot water in a insulated tank, while tankless electric water heaters heat water on demand without the use of storage tank.
Energy Efficiency
The Energy Efficiency of Gas and Electric Water Heaters can be compared by looking at the Energy Factor (EF) rating. This rating indicates how much heat the water heater produces from the fuel source. A higher EF rating implies that the energy efficiency is better. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, gas water heaters normally have an EF rating of between 0.50 and 0.70. On the other side, the EF rating of electric water heaters ranges from 0.75 to 0.95. However, the real efficiency of a water heater depends on a range of factors as well. These encompass the size of the unit, its insulation, and the general design.
The electric water heaters are usually considered more energy efficient than gas models. However, which option is more economical would be a function of the local utility rates for gas and electricity. In areas where electricity is significantly more expensive than natural gas, gas water heater could have more savings in time. This is the case, although it has a lower EF rating.
Easy Installation
The ease of installation is another thing that we must take into account when we are choosing between a gas heater and an electric heater. Electric water heaters are often more convenient to install since they only need the connection to the electrical outlet and cold water supply line. This is the reason they are a good option for those households that do not have a gas line or are aiming to avoid the extra expenses that may come with the installation of one.
However, the gas water heaters need a gas line and proper venting that must be properly installed in order to operate safely. It can, therefore, increase the complexity and cost of the installation process, especially if your home lacks a gas line or the current venting system needs to be upgraded to comply with the current building regulations.
Nevertheless, it should be borne in mind that some of the gas water heater models, like the tankless or condensing ones, may provide more flexible installation options and the need for less venting. These models have become efficient for installation in homes that have limited space or those looking to optimize their energy use.
Size Range
As in the case of gas and electric water heaters, they are available in various sizes, usually measured in gallons.
For gas water heaters, the most common tank sizes are of 20-100 gallons, and 40 and 50 gallons are the most popular tank size for residential use. The bigger tanks are designed to be the right fit for families that use more hot water or those with multiple bathrooms.
Electric water heater models are similar in size and gallon capacity, ranging from 20 to 80 gallons. On the other hand, they are slower in recovering, thus, it is possible that they may need a bigger tank to ensure a sufficient hot water supply for a larger family. Selecting a water heater is a critical step, and it is essential to get a model that can satisfy your household’s needs in hot water.
Temperature rise
Temperature rise refers to the difference between the incoming cold water temperature and the desired hot water output temperature. This factor is essential when selecting a water heater, as it determines how quickly the unit can heat water and how much hot water it can produce in a given period.
Gas water heaters generally have a faster temperature rise compared to electric models. This is because gas burners can heat water more quickly than electric heating elements. As a result, gas water heaters typically have a higher first-hour rating (FHR), which measures the amount of hot water the unit can produce in an hour starting with a full tank of heated water.
For example, a 50-gallon gas water heater with a 40,000 BTU burner can have an FHR of around 90 gallons, while a similarly sized electric model with a 5,500-watt heating element may have an FHR of approximately 65 gallons.
The faster temperature rise of gas water heaters makes them a good choice for households with high hot water demands or those that frequently use hot water for multiple tasks simultaneously, such as running a dishwasher and taking a shower.
Cost Comparison
Initial Purchase and Installation
It is vital to take into account the whole package that includes the purchase price as well as the installation cost when comparing gas and electric water heaters. On average, electric water heaters are cheaper to buy than the ones powered by gas. An electric 50 gallon water heater may cost between $400-$800, while a gas water heater may range from $500-$1,000 for the same size.
Nevertheless, the gas water heaters are usually higher in installation costs because of the necessity of a gas line and proper ventilation. For a gas water heater, the installation cost can be as high as $500 to $1,500 depending on the complexity of the job and local labor rates. Unlike, purchasing an electric water heater is usually cheaper than a gas one, with the price ranging from $200 to $500.
Monthly Energy Costs
Along with the upfront costs, it is also necessary to keep in mind the subsequent energy expenditures that come with using a gas vs electric water heater. The cost-effectiveness of this type is also affected by local utility rates of natural gas and electricity.
When the gas price is cheaper than the electricity price, gas water heaters are in most cases cheaper to operate on a monthly basis. As the U.S. Department of Energy states, a gas water heater averagely consumes $30 per month, compared to the $42 per month needed to operate an electric water heater.
On the other hand, in areas where natural gas prices are high or electricity rates are low, the cost-effectiveness of electric water heaters in the long run may be better. It is crucial to compare the local utility rates and the energy efficiency of the specific models you are interested in, to find out which one will give you lower monthly energy costs for your family.
Lifespan
The lifespan of a water heater can vary depending on several factors, including the type and quality of the unit, the hardness of the water, and the level of maintenance it receives. In general, however, electric water heaters tend to have a slightly longer lifespan than gas models. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, a typical gas water heater will last around 8-12 years, while an electric model may last 10-15 years. This is because electric water heaters have fewer moving parts and are less susceptible to corrosion and mineral buildup. Additionally, electric models do not have a burner or exhaust system, which can be potential points of failure in gas water heaters.
However, with proper maintenance and care, both gas and electric water heaters can last well beyond their expected lifespan. Regular tasks such as flushing the tank to remove sediment buildup, checking the anode rod, and inspecting the unit for leaks can help extend the life of your water heater, regardless of the type.
Maintenance Need
Both gas and electric water heaters require regular maintenance to ensure optimal performance and longevity. However, the maintenance needs for each type can vary slightly.
Gas water heaters require annual maintenance to ensure safe and efficient operation. This typically involves inspecting the burner, cleaning the combustion chamber, and checking the gas lines for leaks. Additionally, the anode rod should be checked and replaced if necessary to prevent corrosion inside the tank. Gas water heaters also require proper venting to prevent the buildup of dangerous gases, such as carbon monoxide.
Electric water heaters generally require less maintenance than gas models, but it’s still important to check the heating elements and pressure relief valve regularly to ensure they are functioning properly. If you have hard water, you may also need to descale the heating elements periodically because hard water contains high levels of minerals, such as calcium and magnesium, which can lead to increased sediment buildup and reduced efficiency over time.
Safety Considerations
Safety turns into the main factor that influences a choice between gas and electric water heaters that come with their own set of hazards. Proper installation, maintenance, and user instructions are the key requirements to deal with those issues.
Gas water heaters can result in gas leaks or carbon monoxide poisoning which can be hazardous if not installed and maintained properly. Leaky or corroded gas lines may result in gas leaking, while a lack of proper venting can result in carbon monoxide accumulation. Without colors and smells, it can be deadly at high concentrations. To prevent gas water heater hazards, only certified technicians must be employed for the installation. Routine checking plays a critical role in detecting any damages or faults.
Electric water heaters are not connected with gas and therefore they do not have this problem. Nevertheless, they also still have the risk of electrical shock or fire. Such risks are attributed to the wiring that is defective or overloaded, which can result in an electrical fire. Beside that, broken heating elements might cause electrical shocks. The electricians with a license must deal with the installation of electric water heaters, and it is advisable to make a routine check in order to detect wear or damage.
Both types of water heaters demand a temperature and pressure relief valve (T&P valve) to prevent the water heated to be too hot and pressurized. Such pressure can be a reason for the explosion or rupture. The T&P valve should be tested at periodic intervals to confirm that it works properly; it should be replaced when it is not functional.
Environmental Impact
Assessing the environmental impact of gas as against electric water heaters requires attention to their energy sources. Natural gas, a kind of fossil fuel, releases greenhouse gases when used for energy, which in turn increases the amount of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere and, therefore, contributes to climate change. Notwithstanding that, it is considered as a cleaner alternative to coal or oil which otherwise may be used as sources of electrical power generation.
Electric water heaters have no direct emissions at the point of use and they are also efficient to use. However, the environmental impact of these heaters depends on where the electricity is produced. Residential electric water heaters which are heavily dependent on coal or oil are a significant contributor to carbon footprints.
On the other hand, the environmental impact is reduced in those regions which favor renewable sources like solar, wind, or hydro resources. Additionally, there are some electric water heater models, specifically heat pump models, that excel in energy efficiency, which sets them apart from the conventional electric resistance models.
How to Determine Which is Better For You?
Choosing between a gas and electric water heater ultimately depends on your specific needs, preferences, and circumstances. Here are a few key factors to consider when making your decision:
- Fuel availability and cost: If you don’t already have natural gas service in your home, the cost of installing a gas line may make an electric water heater the more practical choice. Similarly, if electricity rates in your area are significantly higher than natural gas prices, a gas water heater may be the more cost-effective option in the long run.
- Installation requirements: If you’re replacing an existing water heater, it may be simpler and more cost-effective to stick with the same fuel type to avoid the need for new utility connections or ventilation. If you’re installing a water heater in a new location, consider the proximity to existing gas and electrical lines.
- Hot water demands: If you have a large household with high hot water needs, a gas water heater may be the better choice due to its faster recovery time and higher first-hour rating (FHR). If your hot water demands are more moderate, an electric model may suffice.
- Energy efficiency: If maximizing energy efficiency is a top priority, an electric water heater may be the better choice, particularly if you live in an area with a high percentage of renewable energy on the power grid. However, the lower cost of natural gas may offset the higher efficiency of an electric model in some cases.
- Maintenance and safety: If you’re uncomfortable with the idea of having a gas appliance in your home or don’t want to deal with the additional maintenance requirements of a gas water heater, an electric model may be the better choice for peace of mind.
How to Choose an Efficient Water Heater?
When selecting an efficient water heater, whether gas or electric, there are several key factors to consider:
- Energy Factor (EF): Look for a water heater with a high EF rating, which indicates better energy efficiency. The higher the EF, the more efficient the unit.
- ENERGY STAR certification: Choose a water heater that has earned the ENERGY STAR label, which signifies that the unit meets strict energy efficiency guidelines set by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).
- Insulation: Opt for a water heater with high levels of insulation to minimize heat loss and improve efficiency. Look for units with a high R-value, which measures the effectiveness of the insulation.
- Tank size: Select a water heater with a tank size that matches your household’s hot water needs to avoid wasting energy on heating unused water.
- Tankless or heat pump options: Consider high-efficiency alternatives to traditional tank-style water heaters, such as tankless (on-demand) models or heat pump water heaters, which can provide significant energy savings.
- Proper installation: Ensure that your water heater is installed correctly by a qualified professional to maximize efficiency and safety. Proper installation includes adequate venting (for gas models), insulation of hot water pipes, and the correct sizing of the unit for your household’s needs.
- Regular maintenance: Maintain your water heater according to the manufacturer’s recommendations to ensure optimal performance and efficiency over time. This may include annual flushing, anode rod replacement, and regular inspections for leaks or damage.
Conclusion
Whether to install a gas or an electric water heater is a crucial issue that influences your home comfort, security and finance. Through the proper assessment of your hot water consumption and power cost, you will be able to choose the option that will help you save on energy costs and protect the environment. Recall to keep in mind the fact that the total cost of ownership consists of both long-term energy savings and maintenance costs in order to make an informed decision and thus an economically efficient choice for your home.
Go for JNOD Electric Water Heater
If you are looking for the smartest and most reliable electric water heater, the JNOD Electric Water Heater could be one of the best option for you. Our electric tankless water heater features a space-saving, compact design and an instant hot water supply with no delays. The JNOD Electric Water Heater is equipped with the latest technologies such as temperature control accuracy and energy-saving technology which provides a comfortable and low-cost water heating for your residence. Due to its durable construction and long-term performance, it is the ideal choice for homeowners who want a cost-effective and energy-efficient water heating solution. Contact us today and get your smart electric water heating solution!
